The first Pop! released from American Horror Story in my area is Rubber Man, from the first installment of the creepy, hit anthology series on FX.
Painted to look like shiny black latex, this is an AWESOME Pop! and very representative of the Murder House of Season 1. I love all the details of this vinyl figure; there's even "ear bumps" on the sides of the Pop! which really gives the feel that there is somebody zipped into the skin-tight sex suit. (I'm going to pretend that it's Ben, because there's been no Pop! announced of him yet sadly.)
I can't wait til the remainder of the series becomes available!